Skip to content
Quay

Quay vs Etsy

Quay vs Etsy when the fee you want to leave is Offsite Ads.

Etsy is a marketplace. Quay is a page you share. The fee difference only matters if the buyer still shows up without Etsy’s search.

Etsy’s published pieces, without Offsite Ads

Etsy’s fees policy, read 8 Oct 2026, charges $0.20 to publish a listing and 6.5% when it sells. US Etsy Payments processing, from the help page read the same day, is 3% plus $0.25. The calculator on this site adds those for a price you type. It does not add Offsite Ads.

Quay’s price is only the amount on the pricing page. That page shows a monthly charge, a percent of the sale, or both. This page does not copy a second Quay number. The checkout you paste can still charge its own processing fee. Quay does not charge a listing fee.

Offsite Ads on top

Etsy’s Offsite Ads help, read 2 Nov 2026, charges 15% of an attributed order when the shop has always made less than $10,000.00 in any 365 days. Those shops can opt out. A shop that has made $10,000.00 or more in any 365 days pays 12% and cannot opt out for the life of the shop.

The fee applies when a buyer clicks an offsite ad and purchases within 30 days. It is capped at $100.00 per order. On a $20.00 digital sale the ad fee alone is $3.00 at 15% or $2.40 at 12%, before the listing, transaction, and processing fees. The Offsite Ads page on this site adds those pieces.

Quay does not advertise your listing, so it does not charge an Offsite Ads fee. It also does not replace the sale that ad would have brought.

What you give up by leaving

Quay is not a marketplace. It does not put the file in a public browse, and it does not run ads for the listing. You send the page. Reviews, search rank, and buyers who already have the Etsy link stay on Etsy. Quay can draft titles and prices from an export. It does not move the file, the reviews, or the buyers.

Quay hosts your file. After a buyer pays on Stripe Checkout, Quay emails an expiring download automatically. PDF files are stamped with the buyer’s email.

Related

Questions

Does the fee calculator include Offsite Ads?

No. It uses the listing fee, the 6.5% transaction fee, and US processing read on 8 Oct 2026. Offsite Ads are a separate 15% or 12% from the help article read 2 Nov 2026.

Can I stay on Etsy and turn Offsite Ads off?

Yes, if the shop has always made less than $10,000.00 in any 365-day period. Etsy’s help describes the opt-out under Shop Manager, Settings, Offsite Ads. After the shop crosses that line, Etsy says participation is required for the life of the shop.

Does Quay bring Etsy buyers?

No. You share the page. If the listing only sells because Etsy search or an Offsite Ad found it, the fee is buying that visit.

What Studio costs: $12.00 a month. You keep the sale. Quay does not add a percent. Buyers pay on the checkout link you paste.